Blog Layout

WHY DOES MY BREAD SPLIT?

Jan Schluter • April 18, 2022

cAUSES FOR BREAD SPLITTING

Baking can sometimes be challenging but that is half the fun. How boring it would be if we didn’t keep it interesting by having something knock us from the left field!

Bread splitting and bursting in the wrong places can happen to all of us, and probably have over the course of our baking, even experienced bakers can have this issue. There are numerous factors that can cause this.

Some of the reasons are listed below:


  • Dry or Wet Dough
  • The crust has formed and gone hard too soon, or:
  • Too much pressure has built up in the dough;
  • The dough was either too wet or too dry,
  • The slashing of the dough wasn’t sufficient or you didn’t do it,
  • Under proofing,
  • Shaping and the skin tension.


DRY DOUGH


If the dough was too dry it can form a crust too early before it’s had time to rise, then when it begins to rise it forms cracks which then burst in odd places when the pressure builds up. Steam is important in this stage of baking of some breads like sourdoughs so it’s a good thing to try and use steam.

There are numerous ways to incorporate steam in your baking. If you are lucky enough to have an oven with a steam function then use that during the 1st 10min of baking, then let the steam out and bake dry.


If you are like the rest of us and not have the steam function,  when you turn your oven on to heat up put a pan of hot water in the oven to heat up together with the oven so when you load your bread there is steam in the oven.

You can also pour a bit of hot water into the base of your oven when you load your bread but BE CAREFUL OF THE STEAM IT PRODUCES -IT CAN SPLASH BACK AND BURN.


If you bake your bread in a Dutch oven, once you have loaded your dough on the baking paper & into the Dutch oven place a couple of blocks of ice between the paper and the pot, quickly close the lid and bake as normal.


WET DOUGH


If the dough is too wet it can create extra steam in the bread and add to the pressure that is already building up in the bread by the gases produced by yeast. This will cause your bread to burst in odd spots and not where you have slashed it. Try reducing the hydration of your bread dough.

 

SHAPING AND TENSION


This can have an effect on your bread too, now don’t get this confused with sourdough. When you are shaping a yeasted (not sourdough) bread you need to make sure you don’t leave air pockets in it. What you are doing is creating an outer skin of dough around the mass when you shape your bread and if you leave air pockets these will push their way to the surface of the bread upon baking and create bursts and splits in the bread.

On the other hand, you also need to make sure you don’t make the skin too thin and too tight because if you do that when the bread rises the skin won’t be thick or strong enough and it will rip If this happens then it means your tension was too tight, so there is a fine balance.


The seams of your bread need to be hidden so make sure they are at the bottom of the bread when you put them in the loaf pan to do the final proof (although for sourdough’s in a banneton the seam needs to be on the top so when you tip it out the seam is then on the bottom.)


To create a good seam in a round loaf once you have gathered the dough into the centre of the round with a combination of the side of your hand by your baby finger edge and your bench scraper, move your hand under the loaf creating tension on the opposite side and move it 90deg, do this a few times until you have created some tension.


When creating tension in a rectangular loaf once you have folded the edges in do the same thing as above but instead of turning the dough by 90 deg pull it towards you to create the tension. Then pinch the edges closed or even roll them with your fingers to close the edge. Lift the dough up and place it in the greased loaf tin seam side down.


PROOFING


What does proofing have anything to do with your dough splitting?  – well if it is under proofed it will do more proofing in the oven and behave like a volcano and the gasses will build up and burst out anywhere they can find space to. 


How do you know if your bread is over proofed, under proofed or just right?


If you poke your bread and it doesn’t bounce back and the whole remains its over proofed and won’t have much rise - its exhausted!

On the other hand if you poke the loaf and it springs back like a tramp then it has way too much energy still and is under proofed and can be left a little longer.


Now, if you poke your bread and it springs back a bit but leaves a pock mark (indentation) then its just perfect! So quickly put it in the oven to bake. (hopefully by this stage you have already had your oven on heating up. 


How long does it take to proof a loaf? – well that will vary according to where you live, how hot it is or cold it is or how humid it is so I can’t actually answer that question categorically,  but a loaf can take anything from 30min to 1 hour at room temp to proof – a fridge will slow it down a bit and is excellent for sourdough breads.

For standard yeasted breads it will still proof rather faster than sourdough so don’t think you can set and forget unless you are doing a slow rise and have used a teeny amount of yeast – but then remember to follow your recipe.


I hope this has helped you a little, please feel free to get in touch with me if you have any other questions.

 

Ancient Grains - Sourdough Starter Rehydration and Recipe

Grain growing in field
By Jan Schluter March 6, 2025
A brief description and explanation of Ancient Grains and how they perform in bread
Sourdough Bread
By Jan March 6, 2025
The Sourdough process from Start (er) to Finish
By Jan Schluter February 20, 2025
MOIST HEARTY GRAIN LOAF
soft fluffy tortilla
By Jan Schluter February 20, 2025
Delightfully soft fluffy flour tortilla the family will adore!
sourdough bread basic bread
By Jan Schluter February 14, 2025
Sourdough and Basic Bread making workshops
Soft and Fluffy garlic and herb bread festive wreath on blue round plate
By Jan Schluter November 28, 2024
Soft and Fluffy garlic and herb bread festive wreath on blue round plate
nuts and dried fruit in a dish
By Jan Schluter September 24, 2024
PUmpkin seed and nut bars
soft wholemeal loaf with knob of buttter on slice
By Helium Marketing August 28, 2024
Wholemeal bread recipe from scratch
blueberry loaf with white icing and lemon
By Jan Schluter August 27, 2024
blueberry loaf with white icing and lemon
melting moment biscuits sandwiched together with gluten free flour product bag in background
By Jan Schluter May 30, 2024
GLUTEN FREE MELTING MOMENTS
dough in tin
By Jan Schluter May 21, 2024
the most frustrating part of sourdough baking.... when is bulk fermentation complete?
photo showing the difference between a  tangzhong and Yudane
By Jan Schluter May 21, 2024
A bowl of tangzhong is like a roux, thick paste. A Yudane is a stiff ball of scorched flour
two types of sourdough bread North African
By Jan Schluter April 5, 2024
Recipe explaining how to bake the North African and Chilli bread mixes
Hot cross buns, soft fluffy
By Jan Schluter March 13, 2024
Soft fluffy hot cross buns filled with dried fruit and packed with flavour
weighing tin with water to calculate loaf tin capacity for dough
By Jan Schluter March 8, 2024
How to calculate the loaf tin capacity for bread dough
Gluten Free Banana Bread Mix - The best Ever!
By Jan February 6, 2024
This Gluten Free Banana bread mix is versatile and tastes devine - use overripe bananas for the best flavour
Lamingtons, light sponge coated in decident chocolate and coconut
By Jan Schluter January 23, 2024
Lamingtons baked from scratch - light sponge coated in chocolate and coconut
German Rogbrot or Rye Bread
By Jan Schluter October 27, 2023
Wholesome wholegrain rye bread made with cracked rye, sunflower seeds and caraway
Stacked Sourdough loaves
By Jan Schluter October 16, 2023
Explaining what diastatic Malt is and how to use it in your bread making process, to use or not to use.
Baguettes
By Jan Schluter December 7, 2022
An unbelievably flavourful Baguette is produced from this recipe and it enables you to make baguettes daily.
Wholemeal Bread; Bread
By Jan Schluter December 1, 2022
WHOLE RYE & PURPLE WHOLEWHEAT BREAD WITH ANCIENT GRAIN SOAKER This is a beautifully moist wholesome loaf of bread you will fall in love with!!
ciabatta bread held up sliced
By Jan Schluter October 17, 2022
INGREDIENTS: 8g Risen Flour's dried instant yeast 200g Risen Flour's Durum Semolina 400g Risen Flour's pizza Milano flour (or strong white bread flour) 480g water 11g Salt METHOD Place yeast, 400g flour, 200g semolina , 450g water and 11g salt in an electric mixer. Beat on medium-high speed until just combined and slowly add more water a little at a time and allow to absorb before adding more water. Check the dough and if its not absorbing any more water discard the balance of the water, otherwise add the rest slowly. Mix until full gluten development has been reached - about 25 min in a domestic mixer scraping it off the hook as it creeps up. The dough will be a wet and sticky. Do the window pane test - with wet hands pull the dough apart and it should stretch and become transparent with a clean smooth membrane. You should be able to stretch the dough for around 10cm before it breaks. (dough will be quite wet). With wet hands transfer to a greased bowl cover with a clean tea towel and set aside at room temperature for 1-1.5hrs during this time do 2 sets of stretch and folds 30min apart. ( a stretch and fold is taking one edge of the dough and lift it up and fold it over to the middle, then repeat with the other sides ), OR until doubled in size ( In warmer tempretures it may take less time so keep an eye on it). It should be wobbly and bubbly. Once its rested place the dough gently on your baking tray that has been heavly floured (you can use baking paper too) - cut into shape sprinkle the top generously with flour on top and allow to proof for 30 - 45min more at room temp covered. Preheat oven to fan forced 240°C. Place a saucepan on the bottom of the oven with a rack above it. Bake for 25-30 minutes until bread is risen, golden and bottom sounds hollow when tapped. Cool on a wire rack for 1 hour. Enjoy - if you have any questions please drop me an email or give us a call. Jan
Ciabatta
By Jan Schluter October 13, 2022
Ciabatta bread using our advanced method. Produces a delightful loaf of your favourite Ciabatta - serve as a sandwich - toasted - topped with your favourite toppings!
gourmet savory crackers
By Jan Schluter October 12, 2022
Gourmet crackers which can be adapted easily to your tastes and imagination. These cost a fortune at the shops but are increadably inexpensive to make at home.
german sunflower loaf
By Jan Schluter November 25, 2021
Ingredients for the dough & method A : For the soaked sunflower seeds 75g water 75g toasted organic sunflower seeds B: For the dough 425g Liquid rye levain, mature (See recipe "levains of various kinds" under Blog section) C: 150g Soaked toasted sunflower seeds 120g Wholemeal Rye flour 100g Wholewheat flour 50g High Gluten Bread Flour the Organic, Premium White or our Artisan Single Origin flour will do well 9g Fine Salt For the topping: Sunflower seeds 1: Prep the sunflower seeds by boiling the water and adding the toasted sunflower seeds – leave to soak for 8 – 10hrs 2. Mix (by hand) section B in a bowl and stir to dissolve yeast. Add C and mix with one hand using a squeeze and release motion, until fully incorporated. Transfer to a lightly greased bowl, cover and leave for around 10min. If you use a machine, in the bowl combine B in the mixers bowl and stir to dissolve yeast. Add C and mix on medium speed until fully incorporated, then cover and leave to stand for 7 min. Bulk Ferment: For 30min, no folds and keep covered throughout. For a large loaf – don’t divide For a small loaf divide Shape the dough directly into the loaf pan(s) with wet hands, push dough into the pans and smooth the surface, top with sunflower seeds. Final proof @ 27DegC and 65% relative humidity for a large or small loaf 1 – 2 hours. Or for final proof at 21dec C proof for 2 – 3 hours Baking times and temps For a large 1kg loaf using a convection oven steam after closing the oven ( you can pour boiling water into a pan at the base of the oven). Bake at 245degC for 25-30min on the lowest fan setting for a 1kg loaf. Or if you are baking in a loaf pan ( as opposed to proofing in banneton and tipping onto board) on a baking stone bake at 250degC for 15min, drop temp to 180degC and bake for 30min For a small 500g loaf – as above for the steam process and bake at 245degC for 20min. Or if you are baking in a loaf pan ( as opposed to proofing in banneton and tipping onto board) in a bake loaf pan on a baking stone, bake at 250degC for 15min, drop temp to 180degC and bake for 10min. Tips Make sure your work surface is well covered with rye flour when dividing & shaping the dough (if you divide it). When dough is fully proofed the top of the loaf will dome and crack a bit. Remember that baking times can vary. The best way to ensure the bread is baked is to check its core/inside temp which should read between 98 – 100degC. After baking allow the bread to rest in the pan for 5 min before unmolding it, this will help the bread keep its shape. Unmold onto a wire rack and allow to cool. Even though you may be baking in a pan it is suggested you place the pan on top of a baking stone (like a pizza stone) which will help speed up the baking process and get better results. Enjoy - if you have any questions please drop me an email or give us a call. Jan
sourdough starter
By Jan Schluter November 25, 2021
Levains of different kinds, an explanation
Breadcrumb artisan loaf
By Jan Schluter November 8, 2021
Artisan Loaf incorporating breadcrumbs from a variety of leftover breads.
chocolate chip cookies
By Jan Schluter September 22, 2021
Our favourite Chocolate Chip cookie recipe baked many times throughout our children's childhood. So versatile . Change it up to suit your family and create wonderful memories for you, your family and your community
Ancient Grains Spelt, Emmer, Rye, Khorasan, Sourdough loaf
By Jan Schluter August 7, 2021
A wonderful ancient grain sourdough bread using Emmer, Spelt, Khorasan flours
By Helium Marketing May 24, 2021
All the other ingredients including salt is already added – you do not need to add additional ingredients ( other than whats listed above) to our RISEN FLOUR bread mix. Baking by hand or Mixer (If you are using your bread machine, it is recommended that you use the basic setting and follow their instructions further for bread mix quantities, although it is recommended that you always put the water in 1st then the flours and dry ingredients). Results can vary depending on seasonal changes and temperatures / storage of product, so it may be necessary to adjust the water and flour ratio. Check the dough in the first 10 min of kneading. If the dough is too dry add 1-2 teaspoons of water extra, if too sticky add 1-2 tbsp of dry bread mix. The dough should be forming a smooth round ball.
Soft and spongy Gluten Free Bread Mix
By Jan May 24, 2021
This bread mix is flying out our door - it makes the most devine soft spongy loaf of bread. Add nuts and seeds to your hearts content!
ORGANIC WHOLEMEAL BREAD MIX
By Jan October 24, 2020
BREAD MAKING INSTRUCTIONS for organic wholemeal bread mix
Spelt Wholemeal, gentle gluten bread
By Jan October 7, 2020
Superior quality Spelt Bread Mix. The Ancient grain contains gentle easily digestible gluten ideal for those that suffer with digesting gluten.
Share by: